Timshel: Beyond narratives of good and evil
Throughout history, humans have tended to understand the world through narratives of good and evil.
Whether that be the saints and sinners of biblical tales or the Manichean narratives told by populist leaders the world over, these simple stories are psychologically alluring.
They help us make sense of complexity and provide psychological reassurance. Within these framings, we see ourselves as virtuous, and we see evil as something inherent only to ‘other’ people.
These questions of good and evil are explored in John Steinbeck’s East of Eden, which, more than 70 years since its publication, has found renewed resonance through Netflix’s recent adaptation. Drawing on the biblical story of Cain and Abel, Steinbeck explores whether people are born inherently good or bad, ultimately turning to the Hebrew word Timshel, which he interprets as “thou mayest”. The idea that, whatever our circumstances or inheritance, we retain the capacity to choose between right and wrong.
These reflections resurfaced when I recently watched NAZA; a harrowing documentary which, through interviews with 24 Israeli military insiders, lays bare the systematic killing of civilians in Gaza.
The truths exposed in this film are impossible to ignore. From the arbitrary point system that marked and tracked ‘suspected’ Hamas fighters through their phones, using the code words ‘Daddy’s home’ to pull the trigger and bomb families in their homes; to the descriptions of the acceptable ‘Naza count’ – the number of civilian deaths that could be justified as ‘collateral’ – the testimonies given are absolutely chilling.
As the interviewees use cold, matter-of-fact terms to describe these mechanisms of killing, we see how Palestinian lives are reduced to numbers, targets and acceptable losses.
There is something particularly disturbing about the ease with which these acts are discussed. Yet perhaps this dehumanising language is part of what makes such violence possible. When killing becomes a technical calculation, when civilian deaths are described as ‘collateral damage’, and when responsibility is dispersed across a vast military apparatus, it becomes easier to distance ourselves from the human consequences of our actions.
Additionally, we see how generalising narratives of good and evil are used to justify genocide. As the interviewees describe each ‘Naza’ not as a person, but a potential Hamas member, they are framed as born enemies. Within these naturalising frames, even a child becomes a legitimate target.
The entire film is shocking, but there was one moment that particularly stuck with me, where one interviewee begins to question whether – having participated in such violence – it is him that is evil.
He remembers travelling to Poland in his youth to visit the concentration camps used against his ancestors during the Holocaust. He remembers questioning how so many ordinary Germans had become complicit, how so many had participated in such abhorrent acts of violence. And then, he joins the dots. He sees how he, a good, ‘middle-class’ and ‘well-educated’ man from Tel Aviv, has become part of a machinery of mass killing. It is an uncomfortable but poignant moment of recognition.
We tend to imagine that extraordinary evil must be committed by extraordinary monsters. However, as Hannah Arendt explored in her writing on the banality of evil, participation in terrible crimes does not necessarily require extraordinary wickedness. Ordinary people, acting within institutions and systems they consider legitimate, can become complicit in unimaginable violence. Indeed, there are chilling parallels between Arendt’s description of Eichmann who, despite sending millions to their death, ‘didn’t seem to be driven by a strong hatred of Jews’, and the interviewee in Naza who claims not to hate Palestinians, despite creating systems to ensure their murder.
This is not to suggest that everyone is equally capable of committing atrocities, or that circumstances absolve individuals of responsibility. But it challenges the assumption that evil is something certain people are, rather than something human beings can do.
Perhaps this is what makes these moral binaries so dangerous. When we see us as inherently good, we become less willing to recognise, or even question our capacity to commit harm. When we see them as inherently evil, violence at scale becomes easier to justify.
It is important that we condemn and hold culpable those responsible for genocide. And it is also important that we resist the polarising and hateful narratives – that exist in many forms and that are gaining ground around the world – which dehumanise entire populations and lay the foundations for extreme violence.
Destruction happens when we essentialise the enemy, when we dehumanise and devalue the lives of the ‘other’. Peace becomes possible when we remember that we all have the capacity for good.